The leading sources of stress for cybersecurity leaders? Regulation, threats, skills shortage
A perfect storm of regulation, increased threats and technological complexity is overwhelming cybersecurity decision makers, reveals new research from Symantec.
Four in five (82 percent) security leaders across France, Germany and the UK report feeling burned out, whilst just under two-thirds (63 percent) think about leaving the industry or quitting their job (64 percent).
Surveying 3,045 cybersecurity decision makers across the across France, Germany and the UK, the research – conducted by Symantec in collaboration with Dr Chris Brauer, Goldsmiths, University of London – reveals mounting pressure on the security profession.
The leading source of stress for cybersecurity leaders is government regulation. Four in five (86 percent total, 81 percent UK) reported that mounting regulation, such as GDPR and the NIS Directive, was increasing their stress. Two in five (40 percent total, 33 percent UK) reported concerns that they would be held personally liable for a data breach.
Just over half (55 percent total, 37 percent UK) feared dismissal if a breach happened on their watch. Insufficiently skilled staff (80 percent total, 70 percent UK), the size and complexity of the estate to be defended (82 percent total, 70 percent UK), and the increasing volume of threats (82 percent total, 69 percent UK) are also major contributors to stress.
“Stress dramatically impacts our ability to make good decisions,” said Dr Chris Brauer, Director of Innovation, Goldsmiths, University of London.
“It impairs your memory, disrupts rational thinking and negatively impacts every cognitive function you have. In an industry like cybersecurity, which requires focus, creative thinking, attention to detail and rational decisions in high pressure scenarios – stress can be crippling. Highly stressed workers are far more likely to be disengaged and ultimately quit. In an industry already suffering a skills shortage, this kind of stress can present a significant risk.”
On high alert
Ironically, efforts to protect the enterprise are also increasing stress:
- 79 percent (62 percent UK)) reported that managing ‘too many cyber defence products or vendors’ was increasing their stress levels
- Two-thirds (68 percent total, 54 percent UK) of cyber-security decision makers said they’d felt ‘paralysed’ by the overwhelming volume of threat alerts
- A third (33 percent total, 28 percent UK) reported that threat alerts, designed to help keep a business safe, are making the situation worse due to their sheer volume
- In the face of such huge workloads, the majority of security professionals (67 percent total, 54 percent UK) said their cybersecurity teams left work at the end of the day with threat alerts left unreviewed
This volume is impacting the security of enterprises:
- Already 41 percent (46 percent UK) agree a breach is inevitable
- A third (32 percent total, 28 percent UK) say their organisation is currently vulnerable to avoidable cybersecurity incidents
- A quarter (26 percent total, 22 percent UK) admitted they have already suffered an avoidable cybersecurity incident
“Feeling paralyzed by an overwhelming volume of threat alerts is a common problem for security professionals, and reason why legacy WAFs are typically bought for a compliance check box, and then, turned off. Not only do they flag an unmanageable volume of alerts, but they also block large amounts of legitimate traffic, creating false positives,” Hala Al-Adwan, VP of Technology at Signal Sciences told Help Net Security.
“In today’s environment, security teams need a modern solution that pulls out needles from the haystack. Signal Sciences next-gen WAF surfaces the most important real-time attacks and anomalies in one quick view and immediately alerts teams through integrated ChatOps and DevOps tools, like Slack, DataDog or PagerDuty. We give you alerts that actually matter and contain actionable data. Any team member can easily access this security event data and quickly understand what’s going on within their applications and how to resolve it. They can diagnose, triage, and solve security problems quickly. Any malicious attacks will be automatically detected and blocked—without producing false positives on legitimate traffic,” Al-Adwan concluded.
The challenge ahead
Two-thirds of security leaders (65 percent total, 54 percent UK) feel they are being ‘set up for failure’. However, the overwhelming workload and pressure doesn’t seem to deter them.
The vast majority of security leaders are adrenaline junkies, fully immersed in their work, even when it’s stressful (92 percent UK and total). Nine in ten are motivated by high pressure situations and 92 percent (UK and total) report that they find their work environment thrilling.
“This appetite for pressure is much needed, as the challenges cybersecurity professionals are facing is set to grow,” commented Darren Thomson, EMEA CTO, Symantec.
Many are already challenged by the pace of change and rapid growth of data. Four in five (82 percent total, 70 percent UK) report that having to secure too much data, in too many places, is making the job more stressful. Almost half (45 percent total, 37 percent UK) say technological change is occurring too quickly for their teams to adapt.
“Ever since the internet started connecting computers and systems, cyber defence has largely been a game of reactions,” continued Thomson.
“With new technology, came new threats. As each new exploit emerged, a new defence was created. Organisations and the cybersecurity industry got sucked into an ever-accelerating game of whack-a-mole. There are now too many moles and too many hammers. It’s time for organisations to take a step back, and approach cyber defence in a far more effective way.”
- Head of Penetration Testing, UK based, Flexible location.
- United Kingdom
- Upto £100,000 plus excellent benefits
Head of Penetration Testing needed to join a security consultancy that are delivering client facing penetration testing services around Web app and Infrastructure. Looking for someone hands on that is able to manage a highly skilled technical team of testers. 50-60% of the time is expected to be hands on, other duties will include, but not be limited to; leading and managing the day to day running of the team, mentoring, team upskill, recruitment, reporting, escalation, process improvement etc. Flexible location although south east is preferred. Anyone with Check / CREST experience is highly desirable. MUST be able to achieve SC clearance. UK based role. All details kept in confidence.
- Technical Security Analyst. Immediate opportunity,
- Newcastle upon Tyne
Technical Security Analyst. Immediate opportunity, Technical Security Analyst needed to join a specialist security team. This role will require travel into the office in a hybrid model once industry returns back to the working environment. The Security Analyst must be commutable to Newcastle upon Tyne. This is an Immediate opportunity. An essential requirement of the role is to be able to engage with internal stakeholders so a blend off technical hands on analytical and consultative communication skills. The role will include, but not be limited to; managing and handling incidents end to end, log review, incident analysis, escalation, vulnerability assessment, Automation, Malware Analysis, Threat intelligence, etc All details kept in confidence. https://calendly.com/chris-holt/call-with-chris-holt-dcl-search
- Security Analyst, London. Financial Services. End user.
CH7885. Security Analyst, London. Financial Services. End user. Immediate role. £55,000 Security Analyst needed to monitor and manage a security suite of tools within Financial Servicecs end user . The Security Analyst will be responsible monitoring, configuring, fine tuning, incident management and generally improving the security tool capability. Specific experience with CyberArk, Tripwire Log Center and Tripwire Enterprise is highly desirable). Current experience with Vulnerability management and penetration testing is highly desirable. Specifically the ability to effectively manage 3rd party pen tests. You will be working within a specialist security team reporting to the CISO. Experience working within a regulated end user environment within financial services is highly desirable. This role will run a hyrbid working schedule, partly remote, partly office based in London (once permitted) This is an exclusive role to DCL Search & Selection. https://calendly.com/chris-holt/call-with-chris-holt-dcl-search
- IAM Consultant- Identity Governance
- United Kingdom
- Upto £80,000 plus benefits
Identity and Access Management Consutlant is required for this established business who put their employees first. the role entails • Develop and maintain IAM services. • Further develop IAM tool integration with Service Now to provide automated JML processes and application access requests and fulfilment. • Provide guidance over Role Based Access in terms of Location based Roles, Application Roles and Business Roles and act as SME over any future RBAC project. • Work closely with our other Technology teams on integrating IAM services with Technology and business systems to increase efficiency through automation around areas such as JML processes, application access request fulfilment and attestation. • Work with the Governance Risk & Compliance (GRC) team to provide application access attestations and toxic combination alerting and reporting. • Involvement with Identity Management initiatives such as Single Sign On (SSO) and Privileged Access Management (PAM), to ensure security and business processes are in line with industry best practice. • Assist in ensuring that all IAM capabilities are mapped to internal processes, policies, and standards. Develop metrics to measure and improve the alignment. • Complete monthly review and report on sensitive group access, i.e., service accounts, admin accounts, etc. validating I&O processes are effective. • Provide information to both internal and external Auditors in response to findings. • Collate audit evidence for AAF audit and control reviews, taking responsibility for identifying service and process improvements to ensure compliance with our controls and standards. We are looking for someone with Hands on technical experience with the IAM tools, you need to have been involved in the integration of the IAM solution into 3rd party software like Servicenow, You will have worked with an IAM tools that are focused into Identity Goveranance, like RSA, CA Identity Suite, Fischer Identity, Hid Global, IBM IGL, Net IQ Identity Goverance, Omada, Ping or Oracle Post covid, this role will invovle a mix of home and office work, the business have a number of office spread across the UK so locaton is flexible for this position