Marriott breach exposes more than just customer info
Marriott’s massive data breach exposed more than just 500 million customer records, it is also shining a light on the role cyber-security needs to play when a firm is in acquisition mode, along with the damage that even one slip up by an employee can have on the entire company.
Marriott has not disclosed exactly how cyber-criminals managed to enter the Starwood reservation system compromising 500 million records, but the early action on the breach is leaning toward the malicious actors obtaining employee credentials in some manner and gaining access to the system. And since their presence was in place two years before Marriott’s purchase of Starwood Hotels there was an obvious omission by Marriott during its vetting process of Starwood and its computer network.
The general consensus is the breach did not involve a hack using malware, but a few other possibilities have been broached. Ben Johnson, co-founder and CTO of Obsidian Security, thinks the attacker originally gained entry through an employee error.
"Often threat actors obtain employee-level access and ‘live off the land’, using built-in tools and IT systems to traverse the environment. Furthermore, due to a lot of the reporting being around encrypted data, it’s highly possible that it was a database backup system that was compromised, as the backup systems often have lower security scrutiny than production," he told SC Media.
Phishing has also popped up as one possible path of attack.
"At this point, we can only speculate, but if I had to guess, phishing would be at the top of the list. My second guess would be a third-party vendor compromise – possibly via phishing or other poor security practices like an unpatched vulnerability – that gave them a foothold within the Starwood enterprise," said David Pearson, principal threat researcher at Awake Security.
Sherban Naum, senior vice president for corporate strategy and technology at Bromium, added that once the malicious actor was ensconced in Marriott’s system, however the method, he really went to work.
"Often, hackers will gain a foothold through an unsuspecting user and spend time working their way through the network, escalating privileges in order to access a company’s crown jewels. The longer a hacker has access, the more damage they can do, so this is much more serious than a one-off breach, continuously putting customers at risk of targeted phishing attacks and card fraud," he said.
Another point brought up by Marriott in its breach statement is despite having encrypted customer payment card data it cannot assure those affected that the criminals did not take the keys and access the information. This fact stood out to Michael Daly, CTO, cybersecurity and special missions at Raytheon Intelligence, Information & Services.
"From a technical standpoint, what stood out to me is they appear to have lost the private decryption keys. This demonstrates again that encryption itself won’t secure data in today’s environment. Active monitoring, proactive threat hunting, automation and an overall holistic approach are required for data security," he said.
What exactly happened to the data is also not known at this point, but Michael Thelander, Venafi’s director of product marketing, said the true details may not come out until the stolen data is used.
"Session logging might tell where SSH keys were used while the attackers were in the network, but there’s a real possibility that keys could have been exfiltrated in parallel with the data. If that’s the case, we may not know it happened until newly-decrypted payment card data begins to drive new fraud schemes," he said.
Some of the attacks that could ensue from the stolen data are opportunistic and targeted phishing emails, as well as, phone scams and potential financial fraud, said John Shier, senior security advisor for Sophos.
"At this point, however, it’s unclear what level of exposure each individual victim has been subject to. Until then, all potential victims should assume the worst and take all necessary precautions to protect themselves from all manner of scams," Shier added.
And if money was not the driving reason behind the attack Raytheon’s Daly suggested the attack could be politically motivated.
"This is much more than a consumer data breach. When you think of this from an intelligence gathering standpoint it is illuminating the patterns of life of global political and business leaders including who they traveled with when and where. That is incredibly efficient reconnaissance gathering and elevates this breach to a national security problem," he said.
Another fact this data breach highlighted is the need for, and the difficulty of, doing a proper job vetting a company’s computer system prior to finalising an acquisition.
Marriott closed on Starwood Hotels in 2016, but the company’s internal security team has already determined that unauthorised access to its database had existed from 2014. However, the cyber-security risk involved to the buyer whenever a corporate takeover happens requires greater attention and time be spent examining every digital nook and cranny of the acquisitions network.
"Cyber-security is and should be a critical due diligence component for any acquisition. This includes pen testing, code reviews, SOC reviews and other exams to test internal controls around the security and confidentiality of the target’s assets," said Darren Guccione, CEO and co-founder of Keeper Security.
Shape Security Director of Engineering Jarrod Overson pointed out the difficulty involved in vetting another company primarily the landscape could simply be too big to properly cover.
"This breach highlights the risk of acquiring companies and attempting to integrate disparate technical systems. Marriott may have the best security in the world but absorbing an entire company’s worth of services, servers, and applications opens up a lot of opportunity for incidents and monitoring to fall through the cracks," he said.
Then there is the problem of balance. During any acquisition, there is a need to move the process along as expeditiously as possible, while attempting to be thorough and limit costs. A very difficult trick to pull off.
"Conducting comprehensive security audits takes time, and can slow down the acquisition process. Ultimately, the goal has to be a balance of assurance and economic benefit. Acquirers should look for demonstrable security best practices," said Tim Erlin, Tripwire’s vice president of product management and strategy.
Erlin added the company being acquired also needs to prove its cyber-security house is in order, a fact that could also boost the value of a company to any prospective buyer. If for no other reason than to give an interested party the peace of mind that an acquisition will not result in damage to the buyer’s system.
"There’s a risk that this attack may have spread from Starwood systems into Marriott’s systems," said Matt Aldridge, senior solutions architect at Webroot.
Industry: Cyber Security News
- Lead Cyber Security Incident Response Consultant.
- United Kingdom
Seeking skilled and passionate UK-based individual for a Lead Cyber Security Incident Response Consultant opportunity 3 core skillsets for the role Hands on technical incident response (triage and planning). Business consultancy (engaging with clients). Commercial awareness. Being able to engage in business growth conversations. Consultancy experience is an essential as it the ability to visit clients and the office. Additional experience will include, but not be limited to: Developing incident response strategies, guides and procedures for effective incident handling Proactive and reactive defense plans based on cyber threat actors' techniques Offering guidance, supervision, and fostering opportunities for team development Significant career development opportunities for the right individuals.
- OUTSIDE IR35 Contract- Functional tester- SC clearance Microsoft Windows Server
- Outside IR35 contract
Front End Functional tester with SC clearance needed for an Outside IR35 project. Current valid SC clearance is required Experience with functional testing with exchange, sharepoint, SQL and other applications relating across a windows server Migration to 2019. Must be able to get to Central London 3 days a week. Jira, Wiki documentation and automation experience highly desirable.
- ForgeRock Consultant- UK
- United Kingdom
- Upto £100,000 plus benefits
ForgeRock Consultant/ Architect is require for niche consultancy who are looking to expand their presence within the UK/European Market Looking for a lead IAM architect, ideally with ForgeRock experience but would consider other vendors, But looking for someone who is able to advice and consultant with Clients but have the implementation background so they can get involved in projects as and when needed. Key duties will be: Provider IAM consultancy to clients, with a focus on ForgeRock Product stack ·Responsible for the design and implementation of ForgeRock solutions ·Install and configure ForgeRock stack to meet customer authentication and authorization requirements, ·Design and implement OAuth2 protocol using ForgeRock OpenAM, ·Design and develop OpenAM custom authentication modules, ·Configure ForgeRock stack to protect RESTful API, ·Troubleshoot and support ForgeRock IAM stack. This is a great role to join a niche play as they look to kick of their European expansion
- ForgeRock Consultant- Netherlands
ForgeRock Consultant required for 6 Month Contract This will be a mix of on site and home based, so need people to be based in the Netherlands We are looking for a lead ForgeRock Technical Consultant/ Architect with strong experience of ForgeRock to lead a new deployment project. ·Responsible for the design and implementation of ForgeRock stack ·Install and configure ForgeRock stack to meet customer authentication and authorization requirements, ·Design and implement OAuth2 protocol using ForgeRock OpenAM, ·Design and develop OpenAM custom authentication modules, ·Configure ForgeRock stack to protect RESTful API, ·Troubleshoot and support ForgeRock IAM stack. ·Designed and developed Restful APIs, This is a great project with an expanding leading IAM player within Europe, We are looking for someone with the above experience, who is comfortable hitting the ground running and taking on the reins at the start of a project